Tuesday, July 8, 2014

Art Eyewitness Essay: Mother of Inspiration - Icons of the Virgin Mary and the Rise of Western Art





Mother of Inspiration 

Icons of the Virgin Mary and the Rise of Western Art


By Ed Voves

Inspiration often comes in the unlikeliest of places.

I was recently moved to reflect on the importance of paintings of Mary, the mother of Jesus, by the massed displays of Mother's Day cards at the local supermarket. The flowery designs of these cards hardly rank comparison with Giotto and Raphael. Yet modern ideals of motherhood, like Renaissance Madonnas, trace their origin to a common source, to the ancient images or icons of Mary.

Icons are one of the most profoundly moving art forms of all time. These religious images remain a hallowed feature of the Orthodox Christian churches and are associated historically with the Eastern Roman Empire or Byzantium during the Middle Ages.

Icons devoted to the Virgin Mary, especially in the form known as the Theotokos Hodegetria, were based on the tradition that St. Luke had painted a portrait of the mother of Jesus during her lifetime. St. Luke was also the author of the gospel that contains the Nativity narrative in which Mary so prominently features.

The Walters Museum in Baltimore, one of the finest privately endowed art museums in world, has a rare, ivory triptych showing the Theotokos Hodegetria. Dated to the ninth century, this icon was once painted and is thought to have been modeled on the reputed painting by St. Luke. During the ninth century, this venerated work of art was housed in a monastery in Constantinople, capital of the Byzantine Empire. The original painting has disappeared, leaving the Walters Museum ivory icon as a link with the ancient past. 
 

Triptych Icon of the Virgin and Child with Saints, (tenth century)

The Byzantine icon, then, is a living legacy of early Christianity. Among other themes, icons established a convention for visualizing and honoring motherhood, female spirituality and the sufferings endured by women in times of war and persecution.

This essay will certainly have more to say on the icons of Mary from Byzantium. However, the greatest icon and image of motherhood that I have ever seen was not created in Constantinople. It is Arshile Gorky's The Artist and his Mother.

The Artist and his Mother was painted sometime between the late 1920's and 1936. Gorky's heart-searing work exists in two forms, the somber double portrait, executed in gray, brown and ochre, now in the collection of the Whitney Museum in New York, and a more lightly-hued version in the National Gallery in Washington, D.C.

Both paintings are based on a 1912 photograph of Shushaniq Adoian and her son, Vosdanik, before they fled from Armenia to escape the Turks. The photograph survived their perilous escape attempt in 1915. Vosdanik made it to safety, later changing his name in honor of Maxim Gorky, the Russian writer who championed the cause of the Armenian people.

Shushaniq Adoian died from starvation so that her son could live. She expired in her son's arms.

An estimated one million other "starving Armenians" perished in the Turkish genocide that is obscured by the widespread suffering of World War I and the 1918 Influenza pandemic. The Turkish government still denies it ever happened. If the near extermination of the Armenians is recalled at all, it is because of the derisive remark made by Adolf Hitler, as he planned the Final Solution, "Who now remembers the Armenians?"

 
Arshile Gorky, The Artist and His Mother, (1926-36)

“I shall resurrect Armenia with my brush,” Gorky declared in 1944, almost as a direct rejoinder to Hitler, “for all the world to see.”

A close study of The Artist and his Mother reveals major differences in the way that Gorky composed these portraits in comparison to what painters of religious icons strive to achieve. Yet, I think the two versions of The Artist and his Mother are real - and powerful - icons.

Religious icons evoke the spiritual link between God and humanity. Theotokos Hodegetria may be translated as "Mother of God who shows the way" or "Bearer of God who shows the way." In these icons, the Virgin Mary implores with her eyes and gestures with her hand for the observer to direct his or her attention to Jesus as the "way" to salvation.

Mary's eyes and hands are key elements of icons. A beautiful example appears in the Heaven and Earth, Art of Byzantium from Greek Collections exhibit, which premiered at the National Gallery in Washington and is now at the Getty Museum. The Processional icon of the Virgin Hodegetria, dating to the last years of the twelfth century, was held aloft for the faithful to behold.
 
 
Processional Icon of the Virgin Hodegetria, (late 1100’s) 

The great theologian, Henri Nouwen, evoked the spiritual forces at work in such icons. In his moving book, Behold the Beauty of the Lord, Nouwen wrote:
The Virgin's eyes are not curious, investigating or even understanding, but eyes which reveal to us our true selves. Likewise her hands are not grasping, demanding, or directing, but hands which open a space for us to approach Jesus without fear.

In Gorky's paintings, his mother's eyes are fully-dilated, deep pools of inscrutable energy. She is peering at us or through us with laser-like intensity. The hands of Gorky's mother are unformed or unfinished. Her hands look like they were wrapped in bandages covering wounds from torture or frost bite.

If you look closely at Gorky's mother, the realization slowly dawns that her body - hands and shoulder first - is being erased. Even as the "black holes" of her eyes seize control of us, she is fading from our view. We will remain bound to the presence of her son, however, by the effect of her fixating gaze.

This almost exactly replicates the creative vision of the painters of Byzantine icons, as Nouwen describes in his meditation on the ancient icon known as the Virgin of Vladimir:
Her eyes look inward and outward at once. They look inward to the heart of God and outward to the heart of the world, thus revealing the unfathomable unity between Creator and creation.

Gorky was an artist in the Western tradition, one of the great Abstract painters of the twentieth century. In keeping his mother's eyes directly upon the viewer of The Artist and his Mother, Gorky ignored Western conventions of painting the Virgin Mary that stretched back to Giotto in the fourteenth century.

Theology in Western Europe during the Middle Ages accepted that Jesus was "fully human, fully divine." This was true in the Orthodox provinces of the Byzantine Empire, as well.

For much of that period, Western artists conformed to the Byzantine icon style. The Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York has works by a thirteenth century painter from Florence whose name remains a mystery. The Master of the Magdalen painted some of his works entirely in the Byzantine style. But a fragment of a painting by this anonymous artist around 1280 reveals a remarkable change. Here, a startling sense of the personality of the Virgin Mary is depicted, very much at odds with the otherworldly demeanor of the Theotokos Hodegetria icons.

 
 
 
Master of the Magdalen, Madonna and Child, ca. 1280

As the fourteenth century dawned, it was this new sense of the humanity of Jesus, the Virgin Mary and Christian saints that emerged as the dominant theme of the increasingly influential Florentine school of art. You can see this in the unforgettable Madonna and Child, painted by Giotto during the decade of the 1320's. Look at the way that the infant Jesus clasps the finger of Mary's hand, which lovingly supports her baby son. This small touch is little short of a revolution in art.


 
 
Giotto, Madonna and Child, probably (1320-1330)

Giotto’s Madonna and Child was in keeping with the Byzantine icon type known as the Panagia Eleousa. The Eleousa style emphasizes the motherly warmth of Mary. But despite superficial resemblances, Giotto's painting is acting on a very different emotional level. Giotto's Virgin Mary is an earthly, rather than a spiritual, being.

This naturalism in turn was promoted to the rest of Western Europe, initially for religious works of art. By the 1500’s, greater attention and resources were being devoted to paintings with secular themes. In portraits of aristocratic women and their children, the stress on the humanity of the Virgin Mary and the infant Jesus in earlier works of devotion can clearly be traced.


Paolo Veronese, Portrait of Countess Livia da Porto and her Daughter Deidamia, (1552)

Portrait of Countess Livia da Porto and her Daughter Deidamia by Veronese exemplifies this evolution in the depiction of women in European art. Veronese was a Venetian artist, where Byzantine conventions had earlier held a commanding position. So the triumph of Florentine-style naturalism is notably significant here.

In Veronese's painting, we can see the transformation of spiritual strength and motherly traits of the Virgin Mary in both Byzantine icons and earlier Madonnas from the Italian city-states. Countess Livia is now the focus of attention. The spritely little daughter draped around her arm testifies to her earthly station as noblewoman and mother. A matching portrait of her husband Count Issepo da Porto and their son Leonida would have also established Countess Livia’s role as wife.
 
  
An interesting feature of this impressive portrait is the marten pelt draped over the arm of Countess Livia. The fur of the marten was believed to confer protection on pregnant women. Countess Livia was indeed expecting another child in 1552.
 

Marten’s Head, (ca. 1550-1559

The head of the marten was encased in a golden, jeweled mask, making it into a Renaissance-era rabbit’s foot. By a delightful stroke of collecting luck, the Walters Museum was able to acquire an almost exact duplicate of this curious treasure.

Countess Livia da Porto was no doubt a very devout Christian woman. Likewise, Christianity and folk wisdom maintained a long partnership over the centuries. Yet, the presence of the jeweled martin's head and the lack of any overt Christian symbols in this painting highlight the diminished role of religion in art by the closing decades of the Renaissance.

The status of women in world society has undergone many transformations since Veronese painted Countess Livia. The countess lived in an age of high mortality of infants and mothers, an age of religious wars and rumors of wars. The jeweled marten’s head is a symbol of a time we would not want to see repeated.

Is that also true of icons of Mary in Byzantium and Madonnas from Italy? The “cult” of the Virgin during the Middle Ages and the Renaissance represents an extreme idealization of womanhood at the expense of actual equality for women in Christendom. Thus, icons to a certain extent were products of repressive, patriarchal societies.

Never-the-less, Arshile Gorky’s The Artist and His Mother shows that the Theotokos Hodegetria is still a profoundly moving symbol of female courage and devotion.

The icons of the Virgin Mary and the evolving depictions of the mother of Jesus throughout the Middle Ages and early Renaissance represents a major advance for women in Western society. In pointing the way to Christ as savior, the Theotokos Hodegetria showed that the care of the human soul was a not a matter to be left – exclusively – in the hands of the “Fathers of the Church.” 
***
Text: Copyright of Ed Voves, all rights reserved

Images Courtesy of the National Gallery of Art, Washington D.C. (for the image the Processional icon of the Virgin Hodegetria, which appeared in the Heaven and Earth, Art of Byzantium from Greek Collections exhibit), the Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York, and the Walters Art Museum, Baltimore MD.

Use of the image The Artist and His Mother by Arshile Gorky was granted by the Artists Rights Society (ARS), New York, exclusively for this essay and may not be reused.

Introductory Image: Unknown artist, Portable Icon with the Virgin Eleousa, early 14th century, probably made in Constantinople, miniature mosaic set in wax on wood panel, with gold, multicolored stones, and gilded copper, dimensions: Overall: 4 7/16 x 3 3/8 x 1/2 in. (11.2 x 8.6 x 1.3 cm) Metropolitan Museum of Art, NY, Gift of John C. Weber, in honor of Philippe de Montebello, 2008, Accession Number: 2008.352

Unknown artist, Triptych Icon of the Virgin and Child with Saints, tenth century, ivory, Overall H: 4 3/4 x W: 9 3/16 x D: 3/8 in. (12 x 23.4 x 0.9 cm); Proper left panel: H: 4 5/16 x W: 2 3/16 x D: 3/16 in. (10.9 x 5.6 x 0.5 cm); Middle panel: H: 4 3/4 x W: 4 9/16 x D: 3/8 in. (12 x 11.6 x 0.9 cm); Proper right panel: H: 4 5/16 x W: 2 1/4 x D: 3/16 in. (11 x 5.7 x 0.5 cm), The Walters Art Museum, Baltimore MD 71.158

Arshile Gorky, American (born Armenia), 1904 – 1948, The Artist and His Mother, c.1926-36, oil on canvas, 60 x 50 inches Whitney Museum of American Art, New York, Gift of Julien Levy for Maro and Natasha Gorky in memory of their father
© 2009 Estate of Arshile Gorky / Artists Rights Society (ARS), New York
.

Unknown artist, Processional icon of the Virgin Hodegetria (front) and the Man of Sorrows (back), last quarter of 12th century, tempera and silver on wood, overall size: 115 × 77.5 × 3.5 cm (45 1/4 × 30 1/2 × 1 3/8 in.) Byzantine Museum, Kastoria, Greece.

Master of the Magdalen, Italian, active 1265-1295, Madonna and Child, ca. 1280, tempera on wood, Dimensions: Irregular, 29 1/2 x 18 1/4 in. (74.9 x 46.4 cm) Metropolitan Museum of Art, NY, Gift of Irma N. Straus, 1964, Accession Number: 64.189.1

Giotto, Italian, probably 1266 - 1337, Madonna and Child, probably 1320/1330
tempera on panel overall: 85.5 x 62 cm (33 11/16 x 24 7/16 in.) framed: 128.3 x 72.1 x 5.1 cm (50 1/2 x 28 3/8 x 2 in.) National Gallery of Art, Washington D.C Samuel H. Kress Collection 1939.1.256

Paolo Veronese, 1528-1588, Portrait of Countess Livia da Porto and her Daughter Deidamia, 1552, oil on canvas, painted surface H including addition across bottom: 82 1/16 x W: 47 5/8 in. (208.4 x 121 cm), The Walters Art Museum, Baltimore, MD 37.541

Unknown artist, Venetian, Marten’s Head, ca. 1550-1559, gold with enamel, rubies, garnets, and pearls, H: 3 5/16 in. (8.4 cm), The Walters Art Museum, Baltimore, MD 57.1982

Monday, June 30, 2014

Morgan Library presents Treasures from Bodleian Library of Oxford University



                                                                          
Marks of Genius: Treasures from the Bodleian Library

Morgan Library and Museum
225 Madison Avenue, at 36th Street, New York

June 6-September 14, 2014

Reviewed by Ed Voves
An exhibition of some of the most important cultural creations in world history is currently on view at the Morgan Library and Museum in New York City. The fifty-eight objects on display represent humanity's need for creative expression and showcase the role of genius in shaping civilization.

Make that Genius with a capital G.

Marks of Genius: Treasures from the Bodleian Library highlights the profound importance to humanity of the inspired creator - artist, writer and composer. These are the people whom Daniel Boorstin referred to as "heroes of the imagination." Sappho, Moses Maimonides, William Shakespeare, George Frideric Handel, Jane Austin and J. R. R. Tolkien are all represented here with carefully preserved manuscripts and art works from the collection of Oxford University's Bodleian Library.
 

George Frideric Handel Original conducting score of Messiah , Sept.–Oct. 1741
The role of the genius or the "great man" in history has been aggressively contested since the 1950's. However a visit to Marks of Genius may cause you to reconsider this controversy. The exhibition definitely underscores the way that gifted individuals - i.e. "geniuses" - can change the way we think, see and hear for the better.

A person of genius certainly has no easy task in making his or her contribution to humanity. One of the most poignant and thought-provoking  objects in the exhibit  is a display of thirty scraps of papyrus on which are written verses by Sappho, the first (known) woman author in history.

 Sappho, who lived from around 620 –550 B.C., was so highly esteemed during the classical era that she was referred to as the "tenth muse." Yet, only one complete poem by Sappho has survived, of the nine books of lyric poetry that she wrote. A few scattered fragments like these which date to a second century A.D. copy, have also come to light. The Bodleian fragments were found during the 1700's in a trash dump in Egypt. In an amazing feat of literary detective work they were later recognized as having been written by Sappho.

 

Sappho, Fragments of poems,  copies made in  second century AD

 One of the surviving verses by Sappho has a timeless message, one that the combative Greeks of her era failed to heed and we in the twenty-first century appear equally unable to grasp:

For some, it's an army of chariot fighters, for others, an infantry corps,
For others, an armada of sailing ships, on the dark face of this earth,
That is the loveliest thing of all, but I say it’s this and nothing more:
Whatever you desire with love in your heart.


The exhibition commentary for the Sappho fragments warns of "the vulnerability of even the most famous ancient literature." The ravages of war and religious fanaticism, environmental disasters and the decay inflicted by "moth and rust" take a heavy toll of the "works of genius."

The Bodleian Library, in an earlier incarnation, had been a casualty of the wave of Protestant iconoclasm that had purged England of most of its medieval art and manuscripts, commissioned by the deposed Roman Catholic hierarchy. In 1602, Sir Thomas Bodley, a retired diplomat, conceived the idea of restocking Duke Humfrey's Library at Oxford with theological works to serve what Bodley called the "republic of the learned." 

Eight years later, Bodley conceived an even better idea, indeed a master stroke. In 1610, Bodley appealed to the Stationers Company, the government-chartered guild that regulated England's publishing industry. Bodley petitioned that august body to reserve one copy of every book published in England for the Bodleian. Bodley's empty library thus became the world's first deposit library and a direct forerunner of the Library of Congress. 

In 1623, the Bodleian received the first or "copyright" copy of the most famous book ever written in the English language. This was Mr. William Shakespeares Comedies, Histories & Tragedies. Of course nobody at the time realized the eventual status of the book we now call The First Folio. The Bodleian copy is one of the star exhibits of Marks of Genius.

 
William Shakespeare, Comedies, Histories, & Tragedies (Bodleian First Folio) 1623

 It was a singular stroke of good fortune that the First Folio was published by Shakespeare's friends and fellow actors so quickly after his death in 1616. Incredibly, Shakespeare's reputation went into an eclipse, soon after. This was further compounded when theater-going in England was banned during the Civil Wars which climaxed with the execution of King Charles I in 1649.
Theater made a comeback in 1660 with the Restoration of King Charles II. A new folio edition of the works of Shakespeare was published in 1663. This was the Third Folio, even rarer today than the First, as most are believed to have been lost in the great fire of London of 1666.

Once the "copyright" Third Folio reached the Bodleian, some efficiency-minded member of the staff figured that one edition of Shakespeare was enough. The Bodleian's First Folio was sold and dropped out of sight. Later generations of scholars could only shake their heads in dismay.
The Bodleian got lucky – very lucky. In 1905, a student at one of the Oxford colleges brought the ex-Bodleian First Folio back to the library without realizing what it was or its value. It had been in his family’s possession for decades and was still bound in its original cover. After word leaked out, an anonymous American bibliophile offered the astronomical sum of £3,000 to purchase the First Folio. In a very-English fund-raising effort – no contribution too small – the Bodleian countered the offer and bought back its very special Shakespeare volume.

The First Folio, edited by Shakespeare’s colleagues, John Heminge and Henry Condell, is indeed a very special book. It ensured that all-but two of the Bard’s plays were published for posterity. The First Folio is the unique source for eighteen of Shakespeare’s plays. Without the First Folio, we would not have a number of the greatest plays including Julius Caesar, Macbeth, Cymbeline, Twelfth Night, The Winter’s Tale and The Tempest.

With the Bodleian First Folio on display, Marks of Genius engenders a sense of the mystery and wonder of creative endeavor. Similar treasures include a page from the 1816-1817 manuscript of Frankenstein and personal "keepsakes" owned by the author of this pioneering “sci-fi” novel, Mary Wollstonecraft Shelley. Another special object from the realm of the fantasy is J. R. R. Tolkien's personal design for the dust jacket of the first edition of The Hobbit, 1937.

  



Reginald Easton, Portrait of Percy Bysshe Shelley and Portrait of Mary Shelley

 Marks of Genius is not exclusively devoted to the achievements of independent “heroes of the imagination.” The exhibition is arranged to highlight the “genius loci” or spirit of place. The influence of geography or national heritage marks these contributions to the human community.

Attention to collaborative effort is also made, with reference to the famous remark that great inventions and scientific discoveries are rooted in the pioneering works of others. Genius, as this time-honored expression affirms, always stands “on the Shoulders of Giants.” The numerous maps on display in the exhibition offers special testimony to our debt to the past.  John Smith's Map of Virginia, published in 1612, despite its inaccuracies, provides information on the Native American inhabitants of the the Chesapeake Bay region that would be otherwise lost  to history.

 
 
John Smith, Map of Virginia, 1612
 
One of the most prized examples on display is the Bodleian’s copy of Magna Carta, the charter of rights and liberties which the rebellious nobles of England forced King John I to sign in 1215 at the famous confrontation at Runnymede. The long evolution of Anglo-American legal freedom is traditionally dated to this historic event.




Magna Carta, Issue of 1217

Although the English nobility were protecting their own independence with little thought of anyone else, Magna Carta was a critical turning point. It represents the first step on the road to the Declaration of Independence, the Emancipation Proclamation and other notable events in humanity's struggle for freedom.

 Significantly, the Bodleian’s copy of Magna Carta was issued two years after Runnymede. Bearing the seal of the Royal Chancery, the Bodleian Magna Carta is an official confirmation of what King John had been forced to sign under duress. The English barons were justly suspicious of royal duplicity and they forced his successor, Henry III, to reissue the famous document after John I died in 1216. Magna Carta was reissued on a number of occasions until the definitive version was signed by Edward I in 1297 when the first Parliament was convened.

 The cause of liberty never sleeps and the Bodleian’s copy of Magna Carta is proof of the need for vigilance. 

 One of the exhibition wall texts quotes an 1830 article from the Westminster Review, “Genius is the gift of God, in poetry, painting, or music; but the degree to which that genius can develop itself, I maintain, depends on the opportunity given it by patronage, that is, by employment.”

 The role of the patron is attested to by lavishly illustrated books such as the magnificent copy of the Qur’an, produced in Persia around 1550. The pages are almost symmetrical in shape - but not quite. Perfection is reserved for God.

 

Qur’an, Safavid Shiraz (Persia), 1550

Perhaps my favorite object in Marks of Genius is the beautiful Japanese picture scroll, or emaki, dating to the early years of the Edo period, the mid-seventeenth century. Following decades of fratricidal civil wars and a disastrous invasion of Korea in the 1590’s, Japan settled into a period of peace and diplomatic isolation. Works of art and literature like this emaki were commissioned to emphasize the traditions of Japan at the expense of ideas from abroad.

 In a wondrous display of serendipity, the story told on this emaki, The Tale of Urashima, has a number of themes in common with some of the great stories of Western literature. We can find parallels with the legend of Pandora from Greek mythology, the theme of travelers to a magical realm as in Sir Thomas Moore’s Utopia and the time-bending tale of Rip Van Winkle by Washington Irving. 

 In this Japanese folktale, a fisherman named Urashima, travels to an enchanted palace, the residence of Princess Otohime. Each of the four sides of the princess’ palace presents a view of a different season of the year – all at the same time!

  

Unknown artist, The Tale of Urashima, Japan, early Edo period

 Here we see the leaves of Japan’s signature maple trees tinged with the red and gold of autumn. When Urashima returns home – after an absence, apparently, of only a few days – he finds that he has been gone for many years. He has not aged a bit, until he opens a box given to him by the princess who had instructed him to keep it closed. Instantly, Urashima is transformed into an elderly man.

 This beautiful version of the story of Urashima is a cautionary tale for a society that did not encourage long-distance travel. It also shows the universality of great literature and human genius.

The wonderful treasures on display at the Morgan Library and Museum are preserved at Oxford University's Bodleian Library. But these hallowed manuscripts, pictures and maps cannot be kept in a box. The Bodleian Library is wise to open the lid during travelling exhibitions like this one. Unlike Urashima, these “marks of genius” never grow old.

***
Text: Copyright of Ed Voves, all rights reserved

Images from Marks of Genius: Treasures from the Bodleian Library, courtesy of the Morgan Library and Museum, New York City, and the Bodleian Library, Oxford University.

Introductory Image:     

William Shakespeare (1564–1616) Comedies, Histories, & Tragedies (The First Folio)
London: printed by Isaac Jaggard and Edward Blount, 1623
Arch. G c.7 The Bodleian Library, Oxford

 George Frideric Handel (1685–1759) Original conducting score of Messiah Sept.–Oct. 1741
M. Tenbury 346 The Bodleian Library, Oxford

 Sappho (ca. 620–ca. 550 BC) Fragments of poems Graeco-Roman Egypt, 2nd century AD
MS. Gr. class. c. 76(P)/2 The Bodleian Library, Oxford

Reginald Easton (1807–1893) after Antoine-Philippe, duc de Montpensier (1775–1807)
Portrait of Percy Bysshe Shelley (1792–1822) Sometime between 1885 and 1893

Watercolor & gouache on ivory laid on card, in an ornate gilt frame made by Asprey of LondonThe Bodleian Library, Oxford
                                                                                     
Reginald Easton (1807–1893) Portrait of MaryShelley (1797–1851) Sometime between 1885 and 1893
Watercolor & gouache on ivory laid on card, in an ornate gilt frame made by Asprey of LondonThe Bodleian Library, Oxford
 
Magna Carta, Issue of 1217, sent by the royal chancery to Gloucester
MS. Ch. Gloud. 8 The Bodleian Library, Oxford

John Smith (bap. 1580, d. 1631) A Map of Virginia
Oxford: J. Barnes, 1612
Arch. G e 41(5*) The Bodleian Library, Oxford

Qur’an, Safavid Shiraz (Persia), 1550
MS. Bodl. Or. 793 The Bodleian Library, Oxford

Unknown artist, The Tale of Urashima, Japan, early Edo period (mid-seventeenth century)
MS. Jap. c. 4 (R) The Bodleian Library, Oxford