Art Eyewitness Essay: Old Master Insights - Rubens, Rembrandt and Sir Kenneth Clark

Old Master Insights: Rubens, Rembrandt and Sir Kenneth Clark

By Ed Voves

During the great cultural awakening that took place in seventeenth century Holland, the professional association of artists, the Guild of Saint Luke, admitted amateur members known as liefhebbers. Loosely translated, liefhebber means enthusiast, fan or "lover."

Kunstliefhebbers, or "art lovers," paid membership dues to the guild of Saint Luke. Part dilettante, part groupie, a liefhebber could gain insights into art and into the practical realities of the art world denied to the rest of the Dutch citizenry. Liefhebbers were commercially well-positioned also, on the inside track for purchasing new paintings as they became available. The Dutch were almost always astute businessmen, whether or not they were liefhebbers.

I like to use the term "art lover" in my reviews, as it sounds much better than "museum patron" or "gallery visitor." It is also more accurate. Most people who go to art museums on a regular basis really do love art. They are modern day liefhebbers and I like to think of myself as one too.

I have two extraordinary women to thank for nurturing the art lover in me. My mother, Camille McKee Voves, planted a deep-rooted (if slow to bloom) appreciation of art. My wife, Anne Lloyd, is an accomplished artist. The example of her vision and inspired work ethic, in ceramics and portrait painting, constantly informs my reflections on the visual arts. Thanks to both of them, I have come to realize that the "magic" of art is the result of an uncompromising dedication to depicting the world as the artist sees it.

Sir Kenneth Clark, of Civilization fame, also deserves my "liefhebber" gratitude. If one engages in "name-dropping," why not go with the best?

Portrait of Kenneth Clark

The Tate Gallery in London is preparing an exhibition, opening in May 2014, to explore Kenneth Clark's profound impact on the way that millions of people have come to look upon art and the world. As a writer, scholar and broadcaster, Clark was a worthy successor to the Renaissance humanists he discussed in Civilization way back in 1969.

The final remarks of Civilization, in which Clark reflected upon the promise and perils of the human condition, are among the most moving statements of what it means to be a sensitive, caring person that I know of:

On the whole, I think that knowledge is preferable to ignorance, and I am sure that human sympathy is more valuable than ideology... And I think we should remember that we are part of a great whole, which for convenience sake we call nature. Above all, I believe in the God-given genius of certain individuals, and I value a society that makes their existence possible.
It was a pleasant surprise, recently, to chance upon a book which Kenneth Clark had written back in 1938 while he was the Director of the National Gallery in London. One Hundred Details From the National Gallery was a pioneering correlation of art images and commentary, a liefhebber's delight.

In this wonderful book, republished in a new edition with full color illustrations in 2008, Clark compared aspects of paired paintings from the National Galley collection. His selection of the "details" often highlighted unconventional relationships.

A great student of the way that artists have portrayed the human hand, Clark matched Peter Paul Rubens' Susanna Lunden (1635) with Hans Holbein's Christina of Denmark, Duchess of Milan (1538). Rubens was one of the first great landscape painters, among many other pursuits in his busy life. The "undulating hills and waterfalls" of Susanna Lunden's crossed hands contrasted with the pyramid-shaped form of the hands of Holbein's Duchess Christina as she tightly grips her leather gloves.

Clark wrote that he chose these "details" from the National Gallery's Old Masters "chiefly for their beauty" and because they "have something in common, either of movement and design or of subject and mood."

Clark certainly did not aim at creating controversy through pairing conflicting visions of art. "Great pictures grumble at each other," Clark noted, "insult or even annihilate each other as great men."

I could not resist the challenge of trying out Clark's approach to comparing details of two works of art. I chose two works from the National Gallery of Art in Washington, D.C. These were Rubens' oil on canvas, Deborah Kip, Wife of Sir Balthasar Gerbier, and Her Children (1629/1630) and an etching by Rembrandt, Studies of the Head of Saskia and Others (1636).

Rubens' group portrait and Rembrandt's ensemble of portrait sketches both treat the cycle of life, youth leading to maturity.

In the case of the Rubens' painting, we begin with the baby in the arms of Deborah Kip and follow a succession of her children, each a year or two older, in a circle that leads back to their mother.

Rembrandt van Rijn, Studies of the Head of Saskia and Others (1636)

In Rembrandt's etching, a youthful Saskia is surrounded by a galaxy of portraits of women of various ages, most of whom, if not all, resemble her. This includes an elderly woman who might well have represented in Rembrandt's mind a vision of his young wife in her old age. Saskia, as we know, died in 1642, only few years after this etching was created.

The parallel between these two works, based on the theme of the cycle of life, is only a very loose one. Rembrandt frequently drew or etched works with multiple portrait studies and these may have been intended as nothing more than references for future works, perhaps one with a biblical theme. Clark, in Civilization, observed about Rembrandt's drawings that "one often doesn't know if he is recording an observation or illustrating the scriptures, so much had the two experiences grown together in his mind."

Whatever Rubens or Rembrandt intended with these works, there are comparative "details" in both them that reach out across the centuries and compel our attention. Look closely and you will see two sets of eyes focused directly upon you, one from each picture. The young girl dressed in black, Deborah Kip's daughter, Elizabeth, and "Saskia" wearing the wide-brimmed hat are both intently studying us, with a fixed, deliberate, "knowing" look that is quite unsettling.

 

Elizabeth Gerbier (detail)

Rubens' Deborah Kip, Wife of Sir Balthasar Gerbier, and Her Children

 

In the Rubens' painting, the younger daughter, Susan, is also looking directly at us too, but she is too young to fully comprehend the visual exchange. The black-garbed Elizabeth and Saskia, beneath that extravagant hat, both have taken our measure - and their own. They gaze upon their world without illusion and recognize us as fellow human beings, mortal creatures with strengths and weaknesses, as they were/are.

 

Saskia van Uylenburgh (detail)

Rembrandt, Studies of the Head of Saskia and Others (1636)

Is my reflection merely subjective musing on similar elements of two Old Master pictures? Could I be seeing "eyes" in portraits following me around the room like the ones in creepy, 1940's horror films? Perhaps... not.

My wife, Anne, has noted, that when painting a portrait, she frequently achieves masterly of an eye or a set of eyes early on, during the painting process. A sense of presence or contact is thus achieved, a relationship established between painter and subject that lasts until the picture is finished - and longer.

One eye, Anne observes, frequently is more alert, livelier and more perceptive. Anne calls it the "intense" eye. The other, by contrast, often is a "dull" eye. It is reflective, inwardly focused. The eyes of Rembrandt's Saskia certainly reveal this split focus.

I think that this is true for Ruben's young Elizabeth as well, though more open to interpretation.

One thing is certain about Elizabeth. She has a mature, grown-up countenance far more advanced than we would expect from an adolescent girl. Rubens painted her in this and another other major work while he was visiting London in 1629-30 as the ambassador of the King of Spain and the Spanish government in Belgium. This was the era of the terrible Thirty Years War, a staggering human tragedy which weighed heavily on the mind of Rubens, a peace-loving man, and cast a malign shadow upon the whole population of Europe.

Rubens stayed with Sir Balthasar Gerbier, the father of Elizabeth, during the time he spent in England. As a peace offering from Philip IV of Spain to Charles I of Great Britain, Rubens painted one of his grandiose allegorical works. Minerva Protects Pax from Mars, in the collection of the National Gallery in London, is usually referred to as Peace and War. It is one of the most "Rubenesque" of Rubens' works. It depicts a voluptuous, nude Goddess of Peace being shielded by Minerva or Athena, clad in extravagant armor, from the belligerent "God" of War, Mars.

Peace and War is not much to the modern taste and indeed I held Rubens in low esteem for many years. Fortunately, in 2005, Anne and I saw a great exhibit of drawings and etchings by Rubens at the Metropolitan Museum in New York. The astonishing skill and the inspiring degree of human empathy evident in these works totally changed my appraisal of Rubens.

 

 

Peter Paul Rubens, Portrait of George Gerbier (1629/30)

One of the works in the Rubens' exhibit was a sensational portrait of George Gerbier, a preparatory drawing for Peace and War, now preserved in the Albertina Museum in Vienna. George, Elizabeth, and Susan Gerbier (who looks out from this painting with the same innocent, questioning eyes that feature in the National Gallery family portrait) appear in Peace and War, receiving the fruits of peace.

It was Rubens' desire that this allegorical work would indeed promote the fruits of peace. Although Spain and England patched up their differences (both nations were in the process of internal collapse), the Thirty Years War raged on until 1648.

The Gerbier family was among the casualties of this terrible conflict. Rubens painted this family portrait to thank Balthasar Gerbier for his hospitality. Gerbier, a French Huguenot who was the art agent for Charles I, as well as a diplomat, should have followed Rubens' example as a peacemaker.

Instead, Sir Balthasar Gerbier followed a second, clandestine career in keeping with the murderous politics of the time. He was a double-agent, betraying fellow Protestants in Belgium to the Spanish. He then jumped ship and joined the Dutch, convincing them to let him lead a gold-hunting expedition to South America. He dragged his long-suffering wife and family to the coast of Guiana, where the troops promptly mutinied. One of his daughters was killed in the rioting. Gerbier also betrayed King Charles I during the English Civil War and then had the temerity to ask for his position back when Charles II was restored to the throne in 1660. Gerbier was curtly dismissed by Charles II, and died in disgrace a few years later.

Elizabeth Gerbier, the young girl with the soulful eyes painted by Rubens, converted to Roman Catholicism and joined a convent of nuns. This act may have been motivated by disgust at her father's duplicity or by a spiritual yearning to escape the horrors of the time.

It is vital to remember that a great work of art like Rubens' portrait of the Gerbier family can be appreciated without dwelling on a historical "backstory" like this. But it is also important to consider that "life is short and art is long." The events of the Thirty Years War are long gone. Rubens' art and Rembrandt's art remain.

In probing the eyes and the souls of George, Susan and Elizabeth Gerbier and of Saskia van Uylenburgh, Rubens and Rembrandt acted as intermediaries between them and us. And this dialog between generations will be shared by others. It will continue as long as these great paintings last and as long as art lovers, liefhebbers, remember that we humans "are part of a great whole, which for convenience sake we call nature."

***

Text: Copyright of Ed Voves, all rights reserved
Images Courtesy of the National Gallery of Art, Washington D.C., Tate Britain, London (with www.showonshow.com) and the Albertina Museum, Vienna.

Sir Peter Paul Rubens (and possibly Jacob Jordaens)
Flemish, 1593 - 1678
Deborah Kip, Wife of Sir Balthasar Gerbier, and Her Children, 1629/1630, reworked probably mid 1640s
oil on canvas
overall: 165.8 x 177.8 cm (65 1/4 x 70 in.) framed: 200.34 x 211.14 x 14.61 cm (78 7/8 x 83 1/8 x 5 3/4 in.)
National Gallery of Art, Andrew W. Mellon Fund
1971.18.1

Portrait of Kenneth Clark in Front of Renoir Nude  

Private Collection Courtesy of Tate Britain and Show on Show, www.showonshow.com 

Rembrandt van Rijn
Dutch, 1606 - 1669
Studies of the Head of Saskia and Others, 1636
etching
sheet (trimmed to plate mark): 15.1 x 12.7 cm (5 15/16 x 5 in.)
National Gallery of Art, Rosenwald Collection
1950.1.113
　
  

Peter Paul Rubens
Portrait of George Gerbier, Son of Balthasar Gerbier, 1629/30
Black chalk, red chalk, heightened with white chalk, pen and brown. Small brownish stains on the face, and several brown spots on right edge.
Albertina Museum 8267

                                                                                                                                                                                                                           

Woodcut Revival at the Morgan Library & Museum

Medium as Muse: Woodcuts and the Modern Book

The Morgan Library & Museum,  New York City

 February 21–May 11, 2014

Reviewed by Ed Voves
 
A picture is no longer worth a thousand words.

We live in a world were a tidal wave of imagery threatens to swamp human consciousness. From Google Images and cell phone photography to the omnipresent screen presence of television, people in the twenty-first century glimpse more pictures in a week than a person in the not too distant past would have seen in a lifetime.

Throughout much of history, images were invested with power and sanctity. That is the true meaning of the word Icon. Now, the digital revolution is threatening the ideal of the uniqueness and spiritual force of images.

A new exhibit at the Morgan Museum and Library shows that similar concerns emerged during the age of the Industrial Revolution. Mechanized printing confronted people with a bewildering, disorienting mass of images. A counter movement arose, based upon the technique of carving pictures on wooden blocks to print illustrations in books or posters. This came to be called the Woodcut Revival.

The Woodcut Revival, as its name suggests, was the second great age of carving pictures and designs that could then be coated with ink to produce multiple copies of an image. The first had taken place during the 1500's when Albrecht Durer used the woodcut technique, originally developed in China nearly a thousand years before, to achieve astonishing levels of artistry. In time, Durer earned much more from the woodcut prints of his pictures than from the sale of individual paintings.

The heyday of the Woodcut Revival took place between 1890 and the outbreak of World War Two. But the artist who sparked this renaissance lived nearly a century before.

This was Thomas Bewick, a copper engraver and woodcutter from Newcastle in the north of England. Bewick (1753-1828) used his metal engraving tool, called a burin, to carve on wood. In doing so, Bewick followed French innovators earlier in the 18th century. These included Jean-Michel Papillon, who produced woodcut images for wallpaper. Bewick turned his attention to book illustrations. His woodcut pictures, which are properly called woodcut engravings, are among the most skillful ever created.

Bewick perfected the technique of cutting against the grain of hard, dense types of wood. This enabled him to create intricate patterns of white and black lines. These "hatchings" made his woodcut illustrations look more like drawings with subtle tones of shading than simple black and white prints.

 

Thomas Bewick, Printed receipt for Fables of Aesop, 1818

  
Bewick was so successful with this technique that he began to issue copies of his woodcut-illustrated books with a thumbprint receipt to prove that the work was indisputably his. This example dates from 1818 for an edition of The Fables of Aesop.

 

William Blake, The Pastorals of Virgil, 1821

By the end of his life, Bewick's method of "against the grain" engraving was emulated by many woodcut illustrators in Britain and Europe. But others, like the visionary poet and artist, William Blake, preferred the earlier style of Durer's era. This "primitive" style of woodcut carving became associated with counter-cultural and left-wing political movements. This is important to note because woodcut illustrations were often featured in expensive, limited-edition books favored by wealthy collectors.

During the nineteenth century, woodcuts appeared in two competing roles: the woodcut as talisman of the art of the common man or as aesthetic masterpiece affordable only in elite circles. Medium as Muse, as the Morgan Library exhibit is called. reveals that these two basic categories of woodcuts covered a very wide variety of illustrations. Over ninety woodcut prints, books illustrated with woodcuts, drawings and tools used to create woodcuts are on display in this much-needed exhibit at the Morgan Library. All are from the Morgan's collection.

Emile Bernard, the artist who mounted the first retrospective of the work of Vincent van Gogh, is a key figure in the duality of the Woodcut Revival. Bernard (1868 -1941) was a great admirer of Japanese woodcuts and of the popular prints made in the city of Épinal in northeast France. Yet he chose to illustrate with woodcuts one of the most controversial and "decadent" literary works of the era, Les fleurs du mal by Charles Baudelaire.

Émile Bernard, Les fleurs du mal, 1916

  It took another Englishman, William Morris, to launch the Woodcut Revival in earnest. Morris (1834-1896) was one of the leaders of the Arts and Crafts movement. He had the private wealth to underwrite the operations of his design studio, which specialized in wallpaper, textiles and other furnishings for homes and churches. In January 1891, Morris founded the Kelmscott Press to produce limited editions of classic or inspirational works. The production of these books incorporated all the traditional, artisan techniques that Morris struggled to preserve in an age of increasing automation.

The Works of Geoffrey Chaucer

Designed by William Morris, 1896

Morris and his long-time colleague and friend, Edward Burne-Jones, worked together on a lavishly illustrated edition of the works of Geoffrey Chaucer. Five years of planning, two years to produce, 438 copies in total, the Kelmscott Chaucer was illustrated with eighty-seven woodcuts by Burne-Jones. These are among the last art works in the Pre-Raphaelite tradition. Morris died in October 1896, as his edition of Chaucer came clanking from the hand press. Burne-Jones died less than two years later, in June 1898. It was the end of an era - and the beginning of another.

The Kelmscott Press gained widespread fame for its stunning, handcrafted books. Lucien Pissarro (1863-1944), son of the Impressionist Camille Pissarro and a notable artist himself, established the Eragny Press with the help of his wife, Esther. Pissarro was a great admirer of Japanese prints like his friend, Vincent van Gogh, and he incorporated color woodcut engravings in many of his works. But Pissarro lacked the independent wealth of Morris and he suffered a stroke which limited the number of publishing projects that he could undertake. Never-the-less, the Eragny Press woodcuts made a deep impression on book collectors on the European continent.

The Kelmscott Chaucer and the Eragny Press books were feasts for the eye but not intended for reading. Morris described his edition of Chaucer as "essentially a work of art." But the sheer number of woodcut illustrations in these beautiful books enabled viewers to construct a visual narrative without grappling with the dense, crowded typography.

Félix Vallotton, Le dejeuner en plein air (or, Cinq heures), 1900

Picking up on this, the Swiss-born artist, Felix Vallotton (1865- 1925), produced several series of woodcuts without accompanying text. These presented episodes or scenes whose meanings were easy to grasp. Vallotton's woodcuts totally dispensed with hatchings and simulated gray tones. His woodcuts were small universes of black and white.

Frans Masereel (1889–1972), born in Belgium but active in France, created "wordless novels" with woodcuts unsupported by text. His masterpiece was Mon livre d'heures or Passionate Journey, the story of a twentieth century everyman first published in 1919. A popular Chinese edition appeared in 1933.

Masereel was a hard-working, prolific artist, a painter as well as woodcut specialist. Only a year after Passionate Journey, he published L'Idée or The Idea. In this symbolical work, a naked woman representing free-thinking ideals, is hunted down by the Capitalist "powers that be."

Frans Masereel, Die Idee: 83 Holzschnitte, 1927

A 1932 animated film, L'Idée, inspired by Masereel's wordless novel, was made by Berthold Bartosch, a Hungarian filmmaker, and can be seen at the Morgan exhibit.

Masereel made a lasting impact with his wordless novels, his influence extending to Art Spiegelman's controversial Holocaust graphic novel, Maus, completed in 1991. But it is inconceivable to consider the role of woodcuts in twentieth century American art without studying the career of Lynd Ward.

Lynd Ward (1905-1985) is represented in the Morgan exhibition by a short film documenting his carving technique. Ward was fortunate that woodcuts enjoyed a vogue in advertising circles during the 1930's and 1940's. He was at the peak of his energy and talent, both of which were epic in scope. Ward produced woodcut engravings for such corporate giants as U.S. Cast Iron Pipe & Foundry. Ward's woodcuts gave a populist appeal to the marketing strategy of a company which produced seventy-percent of the metal pipes in the United States.

Lynd Ward, Wild Pilgrimage: A Novel in Woodcuts, 1932

While Ward "paid the bills" with ads for U.S. Cast Iron Pipe & Foundry, he created "wordless novels" which were anything but supportive of the corporate economy. Ward's tales of workers struggling to find their identity in Depression-era America were passionate, almost anarchistic, in tone. Ward's Wild Pilgrimage also probed the psychological state of his protagonist, shifting to reddish brown color to denote a shift from reality to the embattled hero's inner world.

Ward's Wild Pilgrimage shows an obvious debt to the wordless novels of Masereel. Ward had closely studied Masereel’s work while a student in Leipzig during the 1920's. The effect of silent film on the woodcut revival ought to be considered too. But it is fascinating to consider this connection from the reverse angle - the influence of the wordless novel with its woodcut engravings on modern film.

Wordless novels plot the course of narratives exactly as storyboards are used in the motion picture industry. Webb Smith, an animator for the Walt Disney Studio, is credited with pioneering storyboards to plot the sequential development of Disney cartoons such as The Three Little Pigs in 1933. It was not long before feature films were using the technique of plotting, scene by scene, the development of the narrative with storyboards. David O. Selznick hired William Cameron Menzies, who had studied at the Art Students League of New York, to storyboard Gone with the Wind. Alfred Hitchcock was legendary for the use of storyboards in his films of the 1940's and 1950's.

Typee: Wood-Engravings by Robert Gibbings, Penguin Illustrated Classics, 1938

Woodcut engravings, either directly or at second-hand, contributed to some of the most dynamic media of the twentieth century. The Morgan exhibition displays several of the early Penguin Press paperback books which were illustrated with woodcut engravings. It was a long way from the Kelmscott Chaucer, but Morris would certainly have approved.

Woodcuts retain an arcane, time-honored appeal. This is inevitable, no doubt, given the Janus-like nature of the Woodcut Revival. The signature illustration of the Morgan exhibit, Vanessa Bell's woodcut for the story, Monday or Tuesday, by her sister Virginia Woolf, is a case in point. Bell's woodcut appeared in an edition printed on the hand-operated printing press of the Hogarth Press, owned by Virginia Woolf and her husband, Leonard.

But the Morgan exhibit shows that the incredible diversity of woodcut illustration absolutely defies easy categorization. The exhibit is very aptly named, Medium as Muse. There is an almost magical power at work in woodcuts. The act of carving these wondrous illustrations insures the unique, indelible individuality of the artists who create them - and fosters that of the art lovers who behold them.

 *** 
 Text: Copyright of Ed Voves, all rights reserved

Images Courtesy of Morgan Library and Museum, New York City

Introductory Image:
Vanessa Bell (1879-1961)
Monday or Tuesday
By Virginia Woolf (1882-1941)
Richmond: The Hogarth Press, 1921
Bequest of Gordon N. Ray, 1987
The Morgan Library & Museum
© Estate of Vanessa Bell, courtesy Henrietta Garnett
Photograph: Graham S. Haber

Thomas Bewick (1753-1828)
Printed receipt, signed Newcastle 1st October 1818
From a subscriber’s copy of Bewick’s Fables of Aesop
Gift of Dr. Charles Ryskamp, 1981
The Morgan Library & Museum
Photograph: Graham S. Haber

William Blake (1757-1827)
The Pastorals of Virgil
London: F.C. & J. Rivingtons et al., 1821
Bequest of Gordon N. Ray, 1987
The Morgan Library & Museum
Photograph: Graham S. Haber

Émile Bernard (1868-1941)
Les fleurs du mal
By Charles Baudelaire (1821-1867)
Paris: Ambroise Vollard, 1916
Bequest of Gordon N. Ray, 1987
The Morgan Library & Museum
Photograph: Graham S. Haber

The Works of Geoffrey Chaucer
Designed by William Morris (1834-1896)
Wood engravings after Edward Coley Burne-Jones (1833-
1898)
Hammersmith: The Kelmscott Press, 8 May 1896
Purchased by J. P. Morgan, Jr., ca. 1921
The Morgan Library & Museum
Photograph: Graham S. Haber

Félix Vallotton (1865-1925)
Le dejeuner en plein air (or, Cinq heures), 1900
Preparatory drawing for wood engraving
Pen and black ink, over black chalk, on wove paper
Thaw Collection
The Morgan Library & Museum
Photography: Graham S. Haber

Frans Masereel (1889-1972)
Die Idee: 83 Holzschnitte
Munich: Kurt Wolff, 1927
Purchased on the Gordon N. Ray Fund, 2012
The Morgan Library & Museum
© 2014 Artists Rights Society (ARS), New York / VG Bild-
Kunst, Bonn
Photography: Graham S. Haber

Lynd Ward (1905-1985)
Wild Pilgrimage: A Novel in Woodcuts
New York: Harrison Smith & Robert Haas, 1932
Collection of Robert Dance
© Estate of Lynd Ward
Photography: Graham S. Haber
Herman Melville (1819-1891)

Typee: Wood-Engravings by Robert Gibbings (1889-1959)
Penguin Illustrated Classics
Harmondsworth: Penguin Books Ltd., 1938
Bequest of Gordon N. Ray, 1987
The Morgan Library & Museum
Photography: Graham S. Haber
© 2014 Artists Rights Society (ARS), New York / ADAGP, Paris